Should I Stay or Should I Go?
English: Couple on the street with child, Centro Habana, Havana, Cuba. December 2006. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Written by, Kate Oliver, MSW, LCSW-C
I’m going to take a little trip away from talking about parent/child relationships to talking about the relationship between the parents. Just like parenthood, it is impossible for anyone to predict before entering into a relationship just what will happen next. No matter what the reason you had for building your family by birthing, fostering, or adopting children, it will, without question, change your relationship with your child’s other parent and may, at times, leave you scratching your head about whether to stay or go in this relationship.
I have personally found, and I believe it is also true for my clients, that during each stage of my own children’s development I re-live parts of my own childhood. It starts in infancy. It was when my children were infants that I looked at my daughters while rocking them and wondered, “Did my parents look at me this way? Did they feel this awe? This fierce protective feeling? Did they love me this much?” For me, for those questions, the answer was a yes, I don’t remember myself as an infant, but I know it in my soul. I have other, unanswered questions about other stages…the vast majority of us do. Our most intense questions seem to be the ones we have not resolved. People with a history of trauma tend to ask whether their child feels protected. We may compare the expectations of our parents for us to our expectations for our own children. When we pause to think about it, the questions can bubble up seemingly out of nowhere. All parents- even child therapists- wade through these swampy waters.
I can not think of a situation that raises intense questions more for any parent than when the relationship between parents is going through a major transition. The start of parenthood is a major transition. No longer do you have the option of pretending that you are not connected to each other for life. The time for walking away from each other and having the ability to completely cut ties if things go wrong is past. Even if someone seems to have walked away, rest assured, they may be gone, but they are not forgotten by anyone, nor have they forgotten. Similarly, your decision about leaving a relationship also becomes infinitely more complex as you are no longer considering only how this change would impact you but, I assume if you are reading this post, you are also someone who would consider whether that change would impact your children as well. I wish I had easy answers. I don’t, but I have, throughout the years, come across some helpful questions and observations that I use when I have a client, or client’s parents trying to work through these issues. With that in mind, here are a few thoughts to help you in your journey.
1. This first question, I’m going to paraphrase from memory and it comes from author and coach, Cheryl Richardson (her most recent book is “You Can Create an Exceptional Life*” and her radio show is call “Coach on Call” on Hay House Radio). It goes something like this: “If you decided to believe that from this moment on that your partner was never going to change a single thing about themselves, would you want to stay with them?” Let me be more specific: if they never gained or lost a single pound, if they never took you out more, nagged less, spent more or less time with the children, at work or with friends, etc. would you still want to stay with them? This is important because despite our longing to change people, we really can’t. There is no magical combination of words that will create change for a person unless they are ready to change. Take a moment to consider the possibility that your partner will never change, then think about if you still want to stay.
2. If you decide that you would not want to stay with this person unless they make changes, what is it that you absolutely require from your partner in order to stay? In other words, what are the nonnegotiables in order for you to want to be in a relationship? A little warning for this step is that this is a question that tends to bring out our inner critic. The inner critic tells us we should have known from the beginning that we needed that and that it is too late to ask for it now. After all, you decided to have children with this person so, as the saying goes, “you made your bed and now you have to lie in it,” and so on and so on. The critic can be relentless. Let me strongly encourage you to take a moment to tell your inner critic that you are not making the decision based on this question alone, only that this is a part of knowing what to do next. That being said, what is your bottom line on staying in this relationship? Requiring the absence of abuse, emotional manipulation, and dishonesty can seem like no-brainers to some of us, but, if those are things we grew up with, we can easily come to expect that they are part of life and are to be expected. Let me assure you, they are not a part of every relationship and if it is your belief that they are, please contact a therapist to begin to work on loving yourself more. I have met too many people who have said to me that they are staying with the person they are with because they don’t cheat and don’t hit. I’m going to encourage you to go beyond this. If you can’t think of the relationship you would want for yourself, think of the relationship you hope your children will have with a romantic partner one day.
3. This next one is a helpful “re-frame.” I got it from listening to Robert Holden (author of Shift Happens* and host of a radio show with the same title on Hay House Radio). He makes an important point that even if you decide to “end” what you think of as your relationship with your child’s other parent, you are really only ending one part of your relationship. In reality, what you are thinking of as an ending is actually a transition from one kind of relationship to another- from romantic, to co-parenting. If you are anticipating this change, please remember that people can act differently in different situations. I have seen parents where, if I’m being honest, I understand why the relationship ended with their partner, however, that same person can be a “good enough” parent. Sure, they may not do things the way you do them. But, just take a moment to think of every way you have ever seen someone fold clothes. Does everyone fold them the same way? Of course not! Even if the clothes are folded differently are they still folded? Yes. Sure, you may have a preference for how things are done, but your life will be easier if you stay open to the possibility (as long as the other parent is not abusive) that your child’s other parent may have an alternative and acceptable way of parenting as well. Having this attitude can improve your relationship whether or not it stays romantic or transitions to co-parenting.
4. This might be the most important of my tips. For the sake of your relationships with your child’s other parent, your child, and yourself, take really, really good care of yourself. The only thing we can control is how we react to different situations. We cannot change people with ultimatums, threats, and resentment. What we can do is to really take care of ourselves. Have you been telling yourself that as soon as your partner’s issues are taken care of you will____ (fill in the blank, lose weight, stop smoking, meditate)? Guess what? When you do that you are holding your partner up to a higher standard than you are holding yourself up to. Take time to be the kind of person you want to be with. Follow your interests, be loving, take care of your chores around the house, laugh often. When we do these things there are a few possibilities. One possibility is that you will find that you are happier and see how you may have been contributing to the unhappiness in the relationship. Another is that you will find that you are strong enough to leave the relationship if it becomes apparent that it is not healthy for you. Still another is that your partner may take notice of your positive changes and begin to make some as well by your example. I know your children will do just that also.
Perhaps the overall question of staying or going is the wrong one after all. More importantly, we want to ask, “Who do I want to be in this relationship?” If we can ask and answer that question, then work to get to be that person, then we can find happiness either in or outside of any relationship. It is when we stop looking to outside relationships to fix something inside that we find ourselves and when you find yourself to be a person you will always like, that you will always want to be with and around, that you will also find you are able to have relationships with others that meet your expectations as well. I strongly encourage anyone considering separation or divorce from their child’s other parent to seek therapists knowledgable in helping parents to create a healthy co-parenting relationship.
*You can find the links to purchase any books mentioned in this post by clicking the Amazon widgets button at the top, right hand corner of this page. See disclaimer page.
Who’s Who in the World of Mental Health
Written by, Kate Oliver, MSW, LCSW-C
In the field of mental health, you will come across many titles for professionals. It can be confusing to understand what the differences are. Here is a quick primer to walk you through the different types of helping professionals in the mental health field.
Social Workers- We typically have a Master’s Degree followed by a few years of supervision with a mandatory test to obtain a license. Each state has different standards for Social Workers and it is a good idea to check what a license means in your state. In my state, Maryland, in order to have my clinical license I needed to complete my Master’s in Social Work, then have a minimum of two years and 1500 hours of supervised work time. After that I needed to pass my licensure exam. In my state there are also Social Workers that have other certifications that mean they do not have as much training or experience, and or that they declined to take or did not pass the licensing exam meaning they still must be supervised by someone trained to supervise Social Workers. The lens Clinical social workers use when working with clients is typically to look at a person in the context of their environment to see what environmental stressors a client has and to work with a client to see how we can help them better manage within the system they live in. Social Workers do not prescribe medication
Psychologists have a doctoral degree. They also are required to take an exam following their degree and need to be supervised during and after school for a period of time before practicing without being supervised. Psychologists tend to look at patients (Social Workers call them clients, psychologists call them patients) through more of a medical model i.e.- in what ways is this person not functioning? What are the symptoms…let’s treat the symptoms. Psychologists do not prescribe medication.
Professional Counselors have varying ways to describe themselves, Licensed Family Counselors, or Licensed Marriage and Family Counselors. Like Social Workers, Professional Counselors have Master’s Degrees with supervision and testing following their Graduate Degrees, however their Master’s is in Counseling rather than Social Work and they are more likely to be trained in methods akin to a Psychologist, and/or have specific training for their license such as specialization in Marriage and Family work rather than working with individuals. They do not prescribe medication.
Pastoral Counselors have a Master’s or Doctoral degree in Pastoral Counseling. They come to counseling with a spiritual perspective often related to a specific religion and will bring in religious and mental health elements into their work with a client. They do not prescribe medication.
Psychiatrists are trained medical doctors. Psychiatrists have been through a full medical training with all the tests involved with becoming a doctor but, just as a Pediatrician specializes in working with children, Psychiatrists specialized in mental health. They most definitely tend to see patients through the medical model and do prescribe medication. Psychiatrists often meet with patients for about 30 minutes and do medication monitoring. I would highly recommend that anyone seeing a Psychiatrist also see a Psychologist or Social Worker as it is unlikely you will be getting any talk therapy with a Psychiatrist.
Mental health providers may be found in many different places, schools, hospitals, and in private practice. They may provide individual, group, couples or family therapy, or a combienation of all of those. No one group of practitioners has been found to be more successful in treatment than any other group. However, there is one factor that increases the effectiveness of treatment across mental health provider types. It will probably come as no big surprise that regardless of training background or methodology, the strength of the relationship between a client/patient and the provider is the number one predictor for success in treatment. So, if you see someone a few times, and the chemistry is just not there, it is probably time to switch to another provider.
Related articles:
- Finding the right counselor/therapist for you and your family (help4yourfamily.com)
- How to know when you or your child need a therapist (help4yourfamily.com)
Parenting with affirmations
Written by, Kate Oliver, MSW, LCSW-C
My children are learning new and wonderful things every day.
I am loving and supportive to my children.
My children are loving toward me.
As a huge fan of Louise Hay, the mother of the self-help movement, I have come to find the wonderful healing work that can be done via the use of affirmations. Ms. Hay would tell you that every statement is an affirmation. Typically we think of affirmations being statements we say to help us to feel better. I am loving and loveable is a common affirmation people try to say over and over to help change internal beliefs. But people can also say other, unhealthy or damaging affirmations, without even realizing they are doing so. I hear affirmations all the time like this, for example: everything I do turns out wrong, and it seems like everyone I love leaves me. I know it may seem simplistic to say that affirmations can change things but take a moment to see if you can remember words that may have changed your life. Hurtful words, loving words, thoughtful words, all may have played a part in helping you to form who you are.
I remember overhearing my mother say once that my sister was a smart as I was pretty. These words carried a lot of meaning for my twelve year old self. From them I deduced that my mother thought I was pretty (nice), but not that smart (ouch). While I know she would never have wanted me to feel like I was not smart and she has told me many times since that I am smart, I know that those words were powerful and impacted how I felt about myself. As parents our words are formative for our children. In the same way we can use affirmations to help us feel better about ourselves and to retrain our brains and our internal belief systems, we can use them to help our children form their own internal beliefs and set of understandings about how to feel better when life is hard.
One good introduction to affirmations for children is Louise Hay’s children’s book, I Think, I Am. In it, Hay uses child friendly language to teach children the power of affirmations. I have been using affirmations in my parenting for well over a year now, and can tell you it has made a huge difference in my children’s day to day happiness (mine as well). One thing that I think keeps people away from using affirmations is that they believe all affirmations have to be said in this nicey, nicey tone that feels syrupy and sweet. In my time using affirmations with my children, I can tell you this is absolutely not so!
My then six year old daughter, used to have reactions ranging from grumpy and reluctant to downright nasty upon waking up each morning. I actually got pretty irritated with going in to her room each morning to wake her up with a nice song only to be greeted with a moan that I needed to stop singing and demands for me to help her get dressed. However, I was determined to stay positive toward her and to try to set limits. One day, I got fed up with it and said quite firmly something along the lines of, “You know, the things you say right when you get up set the tone for your day. Do you want to wake up saying how rotten things are all the time or would you like to start your day showing love for all you have?” Here comes the affirmation, which I then stated out loud. “I am chosing to start my day happy and to be around people who are being kind to me.” Then I walked out of her room. I can assure you that I did not sound remotely close to sweet and syrupy. I also stated that I was going to take care of myself by leaving the room because I did not want to start my day feeling angry and sour. I believe my tone and questions are what caused my daughter to sit up and took notice. Within a few minutes she had dressed herself and come downstairs to tell me she did want to start her day right. Since then she has mentioned this desire several times. Sometimes in the morning when I wake her up now she still mentions that today she is going to have a happy day and I can tell you that morning wake ups have completely changed for her making our entire morning smoother for everyone.
Perhaps this sounds too simplistic. I know it’s not always so easy because I know you might tell me how your child would follow you out of the room and around the house demanding that you do such and such or this or that. Affirmations are not magical. They do not immediately change the people around you just by you saying them, however, they do help you to change your inner world and your outer world is forced to change as well. Be what I call a “broken record” with your affirmations. As your child follows you around giving you a hard time, continue to state them out loud. It can be the same one over and over again- you know, the same way you have to say “no” twenty times before they get it.
Now that you have read this, I would strongly encourage you to take a moment now to think about the affirmations you are saying to and about your own children. Would you like to change them? If so, write down what you would like to change them to. Need help finding an affirmation? Give me a try. I’ve gotten pretty good at this 🙂
For more information about affirmations, I would strongly recommend you read Louise Hay’s classic book, You Can Heal Your Life. It has been around for a while but it is actually a timeless work. No time to read? I bought it off itunes and listened to it while walking and I highly recommend this way as well. You can easily find this book by clicking on the Amazon widget link at the top right of this page. Please read my disclaimer page first.
4 Rules parents can live by
About 15 years ago I went to a talk given by Joan Borysenko. During her talk, she said she was quoting from someone whose name she could not remember- I’ve tried to look it up since but I can’t figure out who said it either. What she said is that there are four rules for life: 1. Show up, 2. Pay attention, 3. Give what you have to give, 4. Don’t be connected to the results. I heard these words when I was still in college, before I became a therapist and a mother and they have resonated with me ever since, especially as a parent. I believe that if we all incorporate some of the wisdom of these words into our daily lives as parents then we will all be happier, and we will have happier children.
1. Show up. Turn off your cell phone and the television. If you can ever volunteer at school, do it- even if it is only one time a year. Be present with your child in the moment as much as possible.
2. Pay attention. Pay attention to what your child is trying to tell you. Is your child asking you to read a book or watch a television show they really liked? Maybe there is something in the book they really want to discuss with you. Is your child telling you something about himself or herself that you have not been willing to hear? Notice, this step does not say, “Pay attention and judge.” or “Pay attention and fix what you think is wrong.” It says “Pay attention.” Meditation is a good tool to help us(and our children) learn to be in the present moment.
3. Give what you have to give. Another way I think of this rule is “set boundaries.” Again, notice it does not say “give of yourself until there is nothing left.” I think we as parents can sometimes have a hard time with deciding what it is we have to give, whether it be money, time or attention to our children. To me, giving what I have to give means giving something freely to my children or someone else so long as I will not feel resentful or remourseful later that I gave it. This is a hard one but so important to model for our children.
4. Don’t be connected to the results. I would add that you cannot control them anyway and it is time for us all to stop pretending that we do. Sorry folks, but in parenting there are so many aspects of a child’s life that are so far out of our control that we never had a chance anyway. Oh sure we can pretend things are all our fault when they go right or wrong, but any parent with a child that was traumatized, or who grows up to be addicted to something will tell you that was never in their plan for their child. Sure you can monitor what your child is doing but do they ever get into a vehicle with you or someone else? Do you have a television, radio or computer in your home? Well, if you answered yes to any of these, you no longer control the results. Accidents happen, good people can be hurt, children can conduct secret lives right under our noses with no small thanks to technology. We can have the best of intentions and still things can go wrong.
Depressed yet? Please allow me to help with that. There are some things we can control. We can control our own actions. We can become aware of the ways in which we interact with our children and with others around us. We can be a safe, loving, soft place to fall for our children. We can model health and wellness for them in such a way that it would be difficult for them to ignore how wonderful it looks so they will be attracted to doing the same for themselves. Adding a spiritual practice is a good idea also if you believe in that kind of thing. A spiritual practice reminds us that our relationship with our children is just one important relationship and their relationship to their higher power is another (and is none of our business). Doing all of those things brings us right back to the first four steps I mentioned and allows us to live them with grace and dignity for ourselves and for our children.
Related articles
- Two things your kids tell their therapists about you (help4yourfamily.com)
-
Recent
- 6 Tips for Connecting with Your Teenager
- Updates and New Content on the Way
- Making Peace With Your Inner Critic
- Happy Parent Tip #1
- Why Sexual Abuse is Never a Child’s Fault…Not Even a Teenager
- Naming Patterns Changes Patterns
- This is your brain on attachment
- Last Chance for Two Great Opportunities
- Mother’s Retreat Weekend- It’s Really Happening!
- Stopping the Parent Shame and Blame Game
- Making Peace With Your Inner Critic
- Putting together something fun for you!
-
Links





